Ranking Toy Day Events in Animal Crossing

Toy Day is a festive celebration occurring on Christmas Eve throughout the Animal Crossing series; only Wild World lacks the event. Although initially untitled, the event has been called Toy Day since New Leaf.

It features Jingle, the “black-nosed reindeer” in one of two basic roles. In the earlier games, your job is to find Jingle around town repeatedly to acquire exclusive Jingle furniture. In later games, Jingle asks you to deliver presents to each of your villagers.

Jingle: Happy holidays! I'm Jingle, the black-nosed reindeer!

Even though I’ll be ranking my favorite versions of the event from best to worst, I should mention that I love the atmosphere in all four games. The snow, the music, and the festive lights on trees combine to make it a memorable session that almost feels magical. If this event doesn’t get you into the Christmas spirit, then nothing will. πŸŽ„

1. City Folk

Much like the GameCube event, City Folk requires you to find Jingle repeatedly to obtain Jingle furniture. But here, the event is greatly improved over its original incarnation. You have to trick Jingle by wearing a different hat each time. But fortunately, each of your patterns (worn as a hat) can be used to trick Jingle repeatedly.

Jingle isn’t as stingy in this game as he is on GameCube, plus there’s the novelty of being able to go inside animals’ houses when they’re not home!

Jingle, in a villager's house: Oh, ho ho ho...hey.

It can still be a time-consuming event, but it’s possible to rack up a lot of bells. More than any of the other games, in fact. It’s also a lot of fun, and it’s my favorite Christmas Eve event in the series.

Video of Christmas Eve in City Folk

2. New Leaf

New Leaf introduced a completely different objective for the event: Jingle gives you a sack of gifts to deliver to your villagers, and you have to dress up as Santa and give the correct gift to each animal. So how do you know who gets what? You have to speak to your villagers in the weeks before Toy Day and take notes of their hints.

Rolf: You know, I just really want an orange gift from Jingle this year. That simple!

So this event does require more preparation than the others, and you’ll probably want to buy a Santa suit ahead of time, too. But if you’ve been a studious note-taker, Toy Day itself is quick and satisfying. In fact, it’s the fastest Toy Day on this list. So you can get a taste of the festivities, make your villagers happy, and then carry on with your holiday.

But if you didn’t prepare for the event, then you’re really out of luck. Your villagers are going to be disappointed in you, and so will Jingle.

Jingle: I mean, I probably would have been more careful to give the right gifts to the right people, but oh well.

3. New Horizons

The New Horizons event is a gift-delivering event, much like the one in New Leaf. But there are extra tasks required here: You have to craft special wrapping paper, which requires ornaments that are shaken down from festive trees.

While the crafting may be tedious (especially if you don’t have ornaments stockpiled already), the gift-giving is easier than New Leaf. You don’t have to keep track of their wish lists ahead of time, and you don’t need to be wearing a Santa suit. So the deliveries are pretty easy.

Jingle: All you have to do is visit each resident, magic bag in hand, and deliver Toy Day gifts!

But there is an additional component to the event that is optional: Once you’ve given all of your villagers their gifts from Santa, they want gifts from you too. So if you’re a completionist, or just feel obligated to help your villagers, this additional gift exchange really turns the event into something quite long and tedious.

You can give them whatever gifts you want, but they must be wrapped or they won’t accept them. And tracking down all of your villagers for a second time (essentially making 20 deliveries in a row) probably isn’t the way you want to spend your limited, valuable time on Christmas Eve.

Video of Toy Day in New Horizons

4. GameCube

The original Christmas Eve event is also my least favorite. While it still has a festive feeling with the snow and Christmas lights, it’s also quite a pain. You have to track down Jingle repeatedly (as in City Folk), but here you must fool him by changing into a different shirt each time. (And you can’t keep using different patterns like you can in City Folk.) So if you didn’t stockpile a bunch of clothes, you’re not going to get very far.

Jingle: I think you'll find that it's something you like!

But the worst part is that you have find Jingle five times before he’ll even give you the first item! Considering GameCube towns are among the biggest in the series, this is no small task. He can’t hide indoors in this game, but that’s not much of a consolation. I’m generally tired of the event by the time I get the first few items.

Another thing I hate about this event is that Jingle eventually cuts you off, even if you have more clothing to change into. So you can’t complete the set in a single year! It’s a lot of work for just a partial set of furniture. While I may occasionally check this event out just for the atmosphere, this is not a version I spend much time in any more.

Video of Christmas Eve on GameCube

When is a Toy Day not a Toy Day?

Note: The GameCube version of Animal Crossing also has a separate event called Toy Day, on December 23rd. However, there’s not much to it: Tortimer will give you a gift (a miniature car for boys, or a dolly for girls), and that’s it. Since this is not the full Christmas Eve event featuring Jingle, I did not include it in the rankings above.

Tortimer: For Toy Day, I'd like to give you this miniature car.

What’s your favorite Christmas Eve/Toy Day event in the series? Leave a comment below! And Happy Holidays! πŸ¦Œβ„οΈπŸŽ…πŸŽ

Animal Crossing Sticker Book Impressions

I recently got my hands on the Animal Crossing sticker book that was released earlier this year. This post covers my impressions and thoughts about the book.

Animal Crossing Sticker Book cover

The Stickers

Of course, the main attraction here is the stickers…and there are a lot of them. Over 800, in fact. There generally seems to be one sticker of each New Leaf villager, including the RV villagers that were featured on cards from the Welcome Amiibo update. I should note that I didn’t check for every specific villager, but it’s likely that they’re all included. Except, of course, villagers from other game series that were unlocked with Amiibo figures. So there are no stickers of W. Link, Epona, VichΓ©, Cece, Ganon, or Inkwell, for example.

This is one of 16 pages full of stickers.

Aside from the villagers, there are also stickers of fish, bugs, flowers, fruit, balloons, music notes, stars, tools, PWPs (public works projects), seashells, Nook’s leaf icons, trees, furniture, and NPCs (non-playable characters such as Isabelle and Tom Nook).

Not An Album

One thing that should be pointed out: This is a sticker book, not a sticker album. The pages are not glossy, and you will probably not have much success if you try to move a sticker after you’ve already placed it in the book.

Activities

The book itself is basically an activity book for children. You’ll find some word searches, mazes, connect the dots, and pages where you’re asked to unscramble words or count the objects on a page.

The more interesting parts of the book are the ones that encourage creativity. One page shows a town tree and lots of green, open space. You’re asked to use stickers to add trees, a fountain, flowers, and more to improve the look of your town. Another page asks you to design a fun scene for each season (with backdrops of winter, spring, summer, and autumn).

A page from the Animal Crossing sticker book called Map Time! Design your town map.
Design your town.

Some other pages ask you to design the layout of your house, or even make a pattern to use as wallpaper. Another page shows comic strip style scenes with various characters and an empty speech bubble. You’re asked to write in the bubbles to complete the comic strip.

An Appealing Book

While some of the activities are clearly designed for very young children, other activities will appeal to all ages. And of course, everyone loves stickers! If it sounds good, you can buy the sticker book at Amazon. I bought one to give as a gift and another one for myself. πŸ˜€

If you have any questions about the book, just leave a comment below.

Discussing More New Horizons Details

It’s been a week since Nintendo revealed Animal Crossing: New Horizons for Nintendo Switch. Since then, additional details about the game have come out in various articles and interviews. In this entry, I’m going to share my thoughts on some of the more interesting details.

Confirming Neighbors’ House Placement

Source: IGN

When you first start out, two (“or so”) villagers will accompany you on the plane to the island. The “or so” indicates that the number may change by the time the game is finished, but that does sound low. I hope it’s not indicative of a low villager total in New Horizons.

But the more interesting part is that they will check with you before deciding on a place for their home. So if it’s in a bad spot, you can choose where they will live! I’m actually surprised they’re going to give us this much control, but I’m glad to see this happening. No more houses landing on our paths or in other bad spots.

A house blocking the town paths in an Animal Crossing: City Folk town.
I won’t miss this.

Also, villagers will start out living in a tent, just like you do. And they’ll have to pay off their own debt to Tom Nook before they can upgrade to a house. That will be very cool to see your island build up from scratch. It reminds me of building Tarrey Town in The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild (but with even more control, of course).

Changing Your Appearance at Any Time

Source: Polygon

New Horizons will have new skin tones and new hairstyles, and you’ll be able to swap between character features “at any time.” This certainly makes things more convenient. I can think of at least one possible down side, though: It would make it easy to impersonate others during online play. That could cause problems if someone swaps their appearance to look like someone else and then steals an item, tramples flowers, or otherwise causes harm to your island.

The hair options in Happy Home Designer. New Horizons will have a larger selection.

Only One Island Per Switch

Source: IGN

Nintendo confirmed to IGN that you will be limited to one island per Switch system. If you make multiple accounts on your Switch, each account will have a house on the same island. On 3DS, players could simply buy another copy of the game to make a second (or third, fourth, etc.) town. But Switch saves data to the system itself, not the cartridge. So even buying another copy of the game would not help.

Many players enjoy having multiple towns, and I think Nintendo is going to lose out on some game sales by doing it this way. I’m hoping that they reconsider and provide an alternate way of making extra towns. One idea I have is to sell some DLC that allows a second save file on your Switch.

Even though I’m generally not a big fan of paid DLC, I think this makes sense. Creating a second town is something players would normally pay for anyway (by buying another game cart, or another memory card back in the GameCube days). And not providing an option for multiple towns would alienate many of the series’ biggest fans. So let’s hope they change course on this issue.

No Cloud Saves

Source: Gamekult (French)

Nintendo has confirmed that Animal Crossing: New Horizons will not be compatible with cloud saves to backup towns. This is not surprising news, but it’s disappointing nonetheless. They say it’s to prevent cheating; for example, players could save a bunch of money or valuable items to the cloud, drop those items off in a friend’s town, restore their saved town, and then pick up their original items to duplicate items or money.

While I can understand that perspective, it doesn’t seem fair to penalize those of us who don’t cheat. If our data gets corrupted and our towns get erased, there will be no way to recover. And Animal Crossing towns are something that many players put years into. It’s so much more important to a game like this, than it would be to save your progress in a Mario game, for example. I don’t think Nintendo appreciates how important our towns are to us Animal Crossing fans.

It would be nice if Nintendo could reach some sort of compromise. For example, what if a cloud save only saved things like the town layout, villagers, town/shop upgrades, and town history…but not money or furniture/items. We would still have to replace all of our stuff, but our towns would still be intact. That would be preferable to having to start out all over with a new town. And it would make things very difficult for those who wanted to use cloud backups as a way to cheat.

Auto-Save

Source: Mashable

A surprising revelation was that Animal Crossing: New Horizons will save your game automatically! This is quite a departure from how the game has operated since the beginning. I know a lot of players won’t be happy about this, although I don’t personally have a problem with it. Basically, the only times I saw Resetti were after a power outage or dead battery.

This change also puts Resetti out of a job. I imagine they’ll find a new job for him in the game, though. Or maybe he could at least reprise his role that he had in the GameCube game…as the Groundhog Day groundhog mole.

No Direct Connection Between New Horizons and Pocket Camp

Source: IGN

When Pocket Camp was announced, Nintendo stated that it would connect to a core Animal Crossing game, though they didn’t elaborate. Some thought that meant it would connect to New Leaf, but that never happened. So the only other choice would be the upcoming Switch game. However, Nintendo has backtracked and said they won’t connect directly.

And that is perfectly fine by me. The GameCube version of Animal Crossing had several features that could only be unlocked by connecting a Game Boy Advance using a special link cable.

Some of those features made perfect sense and were helpful to players who already owned both systems (like taking the pattern design tool with you, or downloading an NES game to the GBA).

But the main attraction was the tropical island. And it made no logical sense to prevent players without a GBA from visiting the island; the game already has a fully functional version of the island that you can play on GameCube. So it seemed like a blatant money-grab to require the purchase of another system to access something that’s already in the game.

Kapp'n: Now ye can turn off yer Game Boy Advance, if ye feel like doin' so. Me, I don't give a squid.

So I’m glad New Horizons won’t be doing anything similar (even though Pocket Camp is a free download, it still requires a reasonably current smartphone or tablet). And linking systems up can be a cumbersome process that likely wouldn’t be worth the effort anyway. Just put those features into the game by default, please.

Other Stuff

Other details have come out, including confirmation that Isabelle will return in New Horizons. And sharp-eyed viewers have noticed many details from the trailer itself, like the fact that players can wear backpacks and players’ pupils are no longer fixed in place. πŸ˜€

A week after the reveal, I think I’m most excited about the outdoor furniture and path-making tool. Nintendo is clearly giving us more power to customize our towns the way we want them. Those tools will allow us to create truly unique towns.

As someone who has visited hundreds of dream towns in Animal Crossing: New Leaf, I’ve learned how rare truly unique towns are. Lots of towns are beautiful, with lots of flowers and public works projects (PWPs). But after a while, you end up seeing similar towns all the time (as nice as they may be). That shouldn’t be a problem in New Horizons (hopefully), and that will make the Dream Suite (if there is one), even more enjoyable to use.

Is there a certain feature of New Horizons that you’re dying to try out? Leave a comment below!

Update: Voice Chat Requires App?

Just one other thing I want to mention. That first IGN link says that voice chat will “likely be done through the Nintendo Switch Online app.” That sounds like a bad idea, unless they can make the chat play back through the game, so that everyone can hear what’s going on.

Animal Crossing is a social game; much of online play is communication. This isn’t Mario Kart, where you have a race to compete in, and hearing others isn’t crucial. In Animal Crossing, if someone says on voice chat “let’s play tag in the museum,” and only some of the players can hear him/her, that is going to cause confusion and exclude those without the app.

Wii had a separate mic accessory (called Wii Speak) that was used in Animal Crossing: City Folk. The good thing about it was that even those without the mic could still hear the others and keep up with what was going on. Let’s hope New Horizons doesn’t take a step backwards in terms of communication, and provides a way to include everyone.